Part of the Reeve & Co Group · Made in Mickfield, Suffolk, England

Home / Journal / Big Green Egg or Kamado Joe: Which Should You Build Around?

Big Green Egg or Kamado Joe: which should you build around?

Appliances

Big Green Egg or Kamado Joe: Which Should You Build Around?

We build tables and kitchens around both, regularly, and have no commercial reason to favour one over the other. Here is the honest comparison clients ask us for before they choose which ceramic grill to build their kitchen around.

8 minute read · Appliances

Where the two are genuinely similar

Both are ceramic kamado-style grills using the same fundamental technology: a thick ceramic shell that retains heat exceptionally well, a tight-sealing gasket for precise airflow and temperature control, and the versatility to sear at 350°C or smoke low and slow at 110°C on the same appliance. Both hold their resale value well, both have a genuine cult following, and both will outlast a cheaper kettle grill many times over. For the table and housing we build, the practical differences matter more than the brand loyalty either side brings to the conversation.

Where they differ, practically

Big Green EggKamado Joe
Hinge & lid mechanismSimple ceramic lid, lighter to lift, slightly less assistedSpring-assisted hinge, stays open on its own, heavier overall unit
Shelving & accessoriesSimpler out of the box; wide third-party accessory ecosystemMore built-in accessories as standard (side shelves, ash drawer, divide & conquer cooking system)
Size rangeMiniMax, Large, XLarge most common for permanent tablesClassic, Big Joe, Joe Jr equivalents, broadly comparable footprints
Table integrationFelt gasket collar is the standard reference point we template fromSimilar templating approach; cart-based stock stands are usually removed for a bespoke table
A Big Green Egg on an open oak shelf, Essex
A Big Green Egg on an open oak shelf, Essex

What actually decides it for most of our clients

  • Already own one. Most of our enquiries have already chosen their appliance before they come to us — the table is being built to house an Egg or Joe someone already loves, not the other way around. If that is you, this decision is already made; see our guide to building a table for the Egg for the sizes and clearances that follow.
  • Cooking style. The Kamado Joe’s divide & conquer system makes two-zone cooking (searing on one side, indirect roasting on the other) slightly more out-of-the-box intuitive; Big Green Egg owners achieve the same result with a plate setter and a little more practice, and often prefer the simplicity.
  • Accessory ecosystem. Big Green Egg’s third-party accessory market is larger simply through longevity in the UK; Kamado Joe ships with more built in.
  • Table design. Both integrate equally well into a bespoke oak table. The hinge mechanism on a Kamado Joe needs a little more clearance behind it when the lid is fully open; we account for this at the drawing stage either way.

Our honest recommendation

If you do not already own either, go and lift the lid on both at a dealer before deciding — the difference in hinge feel and weight is the most noticeable practical distinction, and it is entirely a matter of preference. We build beautiful, lasting tables around both in equal measure, and the appliance choice will not change how we approach the joinery, the stone, or the clearances we build in.

A Big Green Egg on a stone plinth with an oak shelf, Cambridgeshire
A Big Green Egg on a stone plinth with an oak shelf, Cambridgeshire

Before you enquire

A few things people usually ask

Can you build a table that fits either, in case I upgrade later?

We build to the appliance you own or have chosen, since the felt collar diameters differ between sizes and brands. If you are planning to upgrade size within the next year or two, tell us at the drawing stage and we can discuss designing in some tolerance.

Which is better for pizza?

Both reach pizza-oven temperatures with a ceramic or steel pizza stone accessory. If pizza is the main use case, also look at our comparison of the Gozney Dome and Arc XL, purpose-built pizza ovens some clients run alongside a kamado grill.

Do you sell the appliances yourselves?

No — we specify and build around appliances supplied by you or sourced through our recommended dealers, but the appliance itself is priced and purchased separately from the joinery.

Is one easier to maintain outside year-round?

Both are designed to live outside uncovered; see our guide to winter care for an outdoor kitchen for the seasonal attention either benefits from.

Tell us which you have chosen, or send us a photo of the one you already own, and we will draw a table built to fit it.

See egg & kamado tables · See appliances we specify · Request a drawing & quotation

An Egg built into an oak and stone island
An Egg built into an oak and stone island

The Reeve & Co Group

Five names, one workshop

Reeve & Co

Bespoke joinery and interiors

Square & True

Bespoke English kitchens

Bryn Hall

Made-to-order English furniture

Sporting Cabinetmakers

Gun cabinets and sporting storage

Old Fashioned Bathrooms

Traditional and period bathrooms

Send us a photograph of the garden and what you like to cook.

We reply with a first idea, a guide price and a date to come and see it.

Start a commission WhatsApp the workshop

Reeve & Co Square & True Bryn Hall Sporting Cabinetmakers Old Fashioned Bathrooms

Fire & Oak Outdoors is a trading name of Reeve & Co Interiors Ltd, registered in England and Wales no. 09593800.

Scroll to Top